Every pair of sounding notes, compared with the pure (just) version of that interval. 100 cents = 1 equal-tempered semitone.
| Notes | Interval | Now | Pure | Off from pure | 12-TET |
|---|
Turn on two or more voices to compare their intervals.
Shortcuts: Space play or stop, T switch tuning, number keys 1 to 5 turn a voice on or off.
Thousands of years ago, musicians and thinkers noticed something remarkable: when two strings' lengths form a simple ratio — 2:1, 3:2, 4:3 — the notes they make ring together with a pure clarity. Clay tablets from ancient Mesopotamia describe tuning lyres by fifths and fourths more than 3,000 years ago, and by around 500 BCE the Greeks were writing these ratios down. Later theorists added the pure major third, 5:4, and by the Renaissance musicians were building whole scales from simple whole-number ratios measured from a single root note. Tuning this way is called just intonation.
The problem: just intonation is perfect relative to its root. Venture into another key, or even a chord built on a different degree of the same scale, and the tuning gets… not so good. Singers and string players can bend notes on the fly, but a keyboard can't, and retuning a harpsichord for every adventurous chord or key change isn't practical. So for centuries musicians experimented with compromises (meantone, then the "well" temperaments of Bach's era), trading a little purity in some intervals for usability in more keys.
The compromise that won is 12-tone equal temperament ("12-TET"). Worked out mathematically in the late 1500s, it became the standard tuning for pianos by the mid-to-late 1800s, and it remains the standard for Western music today. Instead of simple ratios, 12-TET divides the octave into twelve exactly equal steps, each one the twelfth root of 2 (about 1.0595) times the one below. In exchange, every interval except the octave is slightly off: fifths by a barely noticeable 2 cents, major thirds by about 14 cents. But it's equally off in every key, so we can play anything we want with consistent out-of-tune-ness (or in-tune-ness, depending on how you look at it). Quite impressive, really.
I wanted a tool that answers these questions and more in a playful, intuitive, visual and audible way.
Daniel Fox is a record producer, engineer and educator based in Massachusetts, USA.
Questions, ideas, or bugs? edulab@wondersmithaudio.com
Try the other Wondersmith EduLab apps, or bring a hands-on workshop to your school or team.
Visit the Edu Lab ↗Time runs left to right, with "now" at the left edge. Pitch runs bottom to top, one colored line per voice. The labels on the right are the 12-TET note positions, so a line sitting above or below its label is literally sharp or flat of equal temperament. Brackets at the right edge of the display measure each note against the lowest note: amber shows how many cents it is from the pure (just) interval, and green means pure. They work with every wave shape.
Each "Try it" button sets up the app, flips back, and plays. Then press T to switch tunings and compare.
A C major triad in sine waves. Switch between 12-TET and just intonation: the E drops about 14 cents, the G rises 2. Can you hear it? Many people hear the just version as solid and more "still."
C major again, this time with a parabolic sawtooth wave and its harmonics showing. Where harmonics from two different notes nearly (but not quite) meet, they beat at the difference in their frequencies, and a yellow label shows how far apart they are and how fast they beat: the fifth slowly (about once a second), the third about 10 times a second. Press T for just intonation: the colliding harmonics merge, the beating stops, and every label turns green, "in tune · no beats." Is the shimmer a flaw, or an attractive timbre?
F♯ major, tuned in C just intonation. Its major third comes out 41 cents wide, worse than 12-TET in every interval. Now change Key to F♯ and listen: the same chord glides into pure tuning, because it's measured from its own root. Watch the Chord intervals panel as every red number turns green. That difference is how far away F♯ really is from C. This is why fixed just intonation isn't as mobile.